passphrases are less secure than passwords.

MASKODING

2 min read

·

10-10-2024

25

0

Share

Are Passphrases Really Less Secure Than Passwords?

The age-old debate: Passwords vs. Passphrases. While many advocate for the strength of passphrases, a recent study by "Passphrase usability and security: A critical review" published in Computers & Security by M.S. Islam, J.M. Joshi, M.I. Ashraf, A.R. Khan, and M.U. Ashraf argues that the common belief that passphrases are inherently more secure than passwords is actually flawed.

Why the Misconception?

The misconception stems from the notion that passphrases are easier to remember. Humans tend to struggle with remembering complex strings of characters, often resorting to easily guessed combinations. Passphrases, on the other hand, utilize a more human-friendly format, often incorporating familiar phrases or sentences. This ease of memorization, however, doesn't necessarily translate to increased security.

The Weakness of Passphrases:

• Predictability: Passphrases, especially those based on common phrases or sentences, can be easily guessed by attackers. For example, a passphrase like "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog" might be readily deciphered by someone with access to common phrase lists.
• Limited Character Set: Passphrases often rely on a smaller character set than passwords, primarily consisting of lowercase letters. This limits the overall complexity and makes them susceptible to brute-force attacks.
• Pattern Recognition: Attackers can use algorithms to identify patterns in passphrases, such as common word combinations or grammatical structures. This can significantly increase the efficiency of cracking attempts.

The Study's Findings:

The study analyzed various passphrase generation and analysis methods, concluding that:

• Entropy doesn't always guarantee security: While passphrases generally have higher entropy (a measure of randomness) than passwords, this doesn't translate to actual security.
• Human-memorability vs. Security: The focus on human memorability often compromises security, leading to predictable and easily cracked passphrases.

So, what's the answer?

The truth lies in a balanced approach:

• Strong passwords: Utilize a combination of uppercase and lowercase letters, numbers, and symbols. Aim for at least 12 characters.
• Passphrase variations: Use a memorable phrase and add unique elements, like replacing certain words with symbols or using a non-standard spelling.
• Password managers: Employ a reliable password manager to securely store and generate complex passwords, relieving the burden of memorization.

Practical Examples:

• Instead of: "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog"
• Try: "T@h#qUickBR@wNfoX! J@mpS oVer Th3 l@zyD0G"

This combines a memorable phrase with added complexity through special characters, capitalization, and number substitution.

Ultimately, the key to security is not just memorability, but also the inherent complexity of your chosen password or passphrase. While passphrases might seem easier to remember, they are not inherently more secure than strong, well-constructed passwords.